about 9 min read
When someone asks you to introduce yourself, what is the first thing that comes to mind? Do you give your first name and surname? Do you say that you are a student? Or do you define yourself mainly through your hobbies? Or perhaps what defines you most is your role in relation to your family members or friends? Even if you do not know who you are right now, would you like to find out one day? If you have ever thought about questions like these, you have been thinking about your identity.
The nature of identity
The answer to the question of what identity is is not simple. Subjectively speaking, it might be best to say that identity shows itself in the feeling of having a firm inner core which gives us a sense of inner certainty about who we are in different situations. This inner core is in fact an organised understanding of ourselves as a person with particular and relatively clear values, beliefs and goals to which we are committed. The psychoanalyst Erik Erikson wrote a great deal about the concept of identity as early as the 1960s.
He believed that identity develops as a person separates from their parents and arises as a result of becoming independent and questioning the values they have held until then. According to Erikson’s psychosocial theory, a person develops throughout their whole life, through a sequence of different stages. Each stage is marked by a basic psychological conflict, and the way it is resolved determines whether our further development will be healthy or whether we will become maladjusted. One of these psychological conflicts is the one between identity and confusion.
Although Erikson attributes this conflict mainly to adolescence, the problem of answering the question of who we are can arise at any age. Identity problems can become especially prominent in late adolescence and young adulthood because of the many questions people of that age face. First, at that time we need to think carefully not only about who we are, what our strengths and weaknesses are and what exactly interests us, but we also need to decide who we want to be in the future.
One of the main factors shaping our further path in life is, above all, the choice between entering the world of work straight after secondary school or continuing our path as students. Of course, if we decide to study, a new question arises: which faculty to choose. Even once we become proud students of the institution we wanted, we may begin to question our earlier decisions. Admit it – you have surely asked yourself at least once whether you are at the right faculty and whether the path you are on will lead you to the goal you want later in life.
Of course, it should be stressed that young people do not face only questions of professional identity; they also have to make important decisions about family life (e.g. when to move out of their parents’ home), about relationships with friends (for example, how to find a balance between going out and socialising on the one hand and studying on the other) and about romantic partners (do we see a future with this person, do we want a life together or not).
Young adulthood seems to be quite demanding because of the challenges it poses to our sense of identity.
But does this apply to everyone?
Can I somehow skip the whole thing?
Erikson says that identity can be achieved in several ways. Some young people experiment with different options and roles and, after careful thought about which identity they feel most comfortable in, eventually commit to a clear set of values and goals that they have chosen for themselves. This identity status is called identity achievement. In contrast, there are people who are still in the process of exploring: they are still experimenting with different possibilities, but have not yet committed to anything specific.
This gathering of information and trying out of activities in order to find the values we will adopt is called a psychological moratorium (moratorium = a pattern of holding back or postponing). Although people in a psychological moratorium have not yet “found themselves”, because they are actively working on it, the moratorium, just like identity achievement, is considered a psychologically healthy and adaptive path towards defining oneself.
Of course, there is also a way to “cheat” and arrive at an identity the easier way.
We can simply take on certain goals and values without exploring alternatives, because our parents, teachers, friends or other influential people recommended them to us. In this way we might choose a faculty only because our parents studied there, or one day take over the family business without having tried to choose or build a career through our own efforts. This kind of identity is called a foreclosed identity. Another easy way of dealing with the problem of identity is simply not to try at all, that is, to give up on ourselves.
The identity status we are in if we have not committed to any values and are not actively trying to do so is called identity diffusion. People in this state usually feel that the challenges of trying to define themselves are too difficult or too threatening. Since identity diffusion means that a person has no clear set of values or interests, we are often unable to make important life decisions on our own and rely instead on luck or on what other people around us are doing.
Identity crisis
From time to time, even if we have defined who we are, we may begin to redefine our own individuality. If we experience a certain level of anxiety and uncertainty while doing so, we speak of an identity crisis. The psychologist Roy Baumeister describes two crises: identity deficit and identity conflict.
An identity deficit is the emptiness created by rejecting old beliefs and goals.
This kind of crisis is common among students, because at university they are exposed to a great many new ideas and values, and new knowledge and exchanging views with fellow students and lecturers encourage them to question the beliefs they have held until then.
An identity conflict refers to the incompatibility of two or more of our roles. These are usually conflicts in which two or more options attract us equally, but are opposed to one another.
This kind of conflict can result in feelings of guilt if we decide to reject one part of ourselves in favour of another.
Fortunately, with considerable effort and persistence, identity crises can be resolved successfully. Baumeister believes that the resolution takes place in two steps: first we need to decide which values are most important to us, and then we need to turn those values into concrete behaviour. Let us say you have a conflict between the identity of a sociable person with lots of friends and the identity of a successful student.
One way you could resolve this conflict is to a) decide that at this stage of your life being a successful student is the most important thing to you and b) devote yourself to intensive studying in order to achieve that goal.
There is another way you can resolve an identity crisis: you can decide to try to keep a balance between different roles.
For example, you can accept that you might not be the best student in your year, but that in return you will have more time for hobbies, friends and family.
What is a particular identity status associated with?
Identity achievement and moratorium
Higher self-esteem
More frequent use of critical and abstract thinking
More skilled in moral reasoning
Foreclosed identity
Dogmatic, rigid and intolerant
Self-esteem depends on other people’s approval
Diffused identity
Academic difficulties and difficulties with time management
A sense of deep apathy and hopelessness about one’s own future
In search of identity
Since building an identity is by no means an easy task, here are some recommendations to help you discover who you are as easily as possible:
Try to be flexible and open to new values, ideas and opinions
Do not reject other people’s views straight away; instead, try to see the world from their perspective
Bear in mind that there is not always an absolute truth, but be careful not to go too far the other way and believe that nothing can ever be known for certain
Use your studies as an opportunity to explore as much as possible: take part as much as you can in discussions with fellow students and lecturers, and deliberately enrol in an elective course that you would not normally choose or whose benefit you do not see straight away
Read as much as possible (and not only academic literature)
Take up a leisure activity that has always interested you but for which you have never found the time
If you are unsure about your further professional development, there is always the option of career guidance
If you are sure that your current faculty does not interest you after all and is not for you, it is better to change it in time than to spend your whole life doing something that will not make you happy
Try to see every event as an opportunity that can contribute to your development
Ask yourself from time to time whether you are happy with the direction your life is taking, and if you are not, think about what you could change and how
For those who want to know more:
Berk, L.
E. (2008). Psihologija cjeloživotnog obrazovanja. Jastrebarsko: Naklada Slap.
Erikson, E.H. (1976). Omladina, kriza, identifikacija. Titograd: Pobjeda
Larsen, R. J., Buss, D. M. (2008). Psihologija ličnosti. Jastrebarsko: Naklada Slap.