about 11 min read
Do you think you are a good person? Do you feel that you are honest, hard-working and willing to help other people? When you look back on your life, can you say that you have become exactly the person you want to be, or do you think there is still a long way to go? If most of the time you are convinced that you are failing to meet your own expectations and that you are not the best possible version of yourself, you may begin to experience problems with self-esteem as a reaction to judging certain aspects of your self-concept negatively.
How low self-esteem develops
Psychologists (e.g.
Aronson, Wilson and Akert, 2005) state that self-esteem is essentially the rating we give ourselves on dimensions such as good–bad, interesting–uninteresting, capable–incapable, etc. So when we talk about self-esteem, we mean a person’s assessment of their own worth, which arises as the final sum of all their positive and negative reactions to their self-concept.
Although self-esteem is often understood as a general assessment of oneself, that is, as a single concept, psychologists believe that there are in fact several kinds of it, such as social self-esteem, academic self-esteem or self-esteem related to appearance (e.g.
Berk, 2008; Larsen and Buss, 2008). In other words, we can be proud of our achievements at university and have very high academic self-esteem, while at the same time thinking that we are not successful enough in social interactions and having problems with social self-esteem. Interestingly, even though several areas of self-esteem can be identified, there is a moderate link between them, which means that people who rate themselves positively in one area often have high self-esteem in other areas as well.
So we can say that self-esteem is partly a specific trait, because it depends on a particular area of our life, but that it is also partly general.
How low self-esteem develops
Many factors influence the development of our self-esteem as we grow up. First of all, there is the way our parents bring us up. Some parents use authoritative parenting, that is, warm and positive behaviour that shows children they are valued and loved, while setting clear and objective expectations and boundaries. According to Berk (2008), this kind of upbringing encourages the development of high self-esteem in children. On the other hand, when parents are too controlling and make decisions for their children themselves, the children take on a sense of inadequacy and insecurity, which is linked to lower self-esteem.
A third type of upbringing, in which children are overindulged and allowed to do whatever they want, is linked to fragile and unrealistically high self-esteem. Such children grow into people with adjustment problems, who react with anger to any criticism or threat to their self-concept.
Cultural context is also linked to the development of self-esteem. For example, Berk (2008) and Pervin, Cervone and John (2008) state that Western culture fosters individualism and encourages people to focus on themselves and praise their own achievements, which promotes unrealistically high self-esteem in a large proportion of people.
Unlike Western culture, collectivist societies such as China and Japan encourage virtues such as modesty, harmony and praising others rather than oneself. As a result, people in such cultures have somewhat lower self-esteem than people from Western cultures, despite objectively higher achievement in some areas of life (e.g. Chinese and Japanese children achieve more at school than children from North America, but have lower self-esteem).
At the individual level, low self-esteem is linked to unhelpful ways of explaining success and failure.
People with low self-esteem blame themselves for failures and believe that they cannot change their abilities through effort, which is why they feel a loss of control on particularly difficult tasks, and this strengthens their feelings of inferiority and low self-esteem. Even when they succeed, such people put it down to luck or some other external factor.
People with high self-esteem, by contrast, are as a rule those who as children got into the habit of attributing their successes to their abilities, and their failures to external factors such as not putting in enough effort or the task being very difficult.
How do people with low self-esteem react to criticism?
People with self-esteem problems tend to keep them going because of the unhelpful way they react to negative feedback. They experience any failure or criticism as something that confirms their already poor self-image.
This kind of “proof” of their failure holds them back in later tasks and, instead of putting in extra effort to succeed, they either try even less or give up on the task, which keeps their self-esteem low. People with high self-esteem, by contrast, do not automatically accept negative feedback, because it does not fit their positive self-concept. Instead of giving up, they see their earlier failure as chance or a mistake and put extra effort into the next tasks, because they are highly motivated to maintain their view of themselves as successful people.
The link between self-esteem and coping with negative events
All of us experience failures, disappointments and losses in life from time to time. How we cope with them depends, among other things, on our self-esteem. When people with high self-esteem experience a negative event, they tend to focus on those areas of their life in which they are still successful. For example, if we fail an exam at university, we will not let it affect our self-concept too negatively; instead we will focus on other courses in which we are doing well, and also on areas outside university, such as our relationships with family and peers and our hobbies.
In other words, what the psychologist Patricia Linville (1987) observed is that people with high self-esteem have a complex self-concept made up of many parts, so that failure in some aspects of their self-concept can be cushioned by success in others. By contrast, the self-concept of people with low self-esteem is usually simple (for example, defining themselves only or mainly as a student), so they experience failure in one area as something that truly defines them and that makes them lose their sense of self-worth.
Another strategy typical of people with low self-esteem for coping with failure is wanting to avoid it at all costs.
Faced with a situation in which there is a high risk of failure but which also offers the possibility of exceptional success, people with low self-esteem will rather try to avoid it so as not to put themselves in a position where they could fail at all, because they are motivated by a desire to protect their self-concept.
By contrast, people who value themselves positively will be motivated to raise their self-concept even further and will be more willing to take on new challenges that offer them the chance to succeed.
How changeable is self-esteem?
Self-esteem is not a fixed characteristic of a person; rather, it fluctuates around an average level that is typical for each individual. This means that it can change a little for the better or for the worse over a certain period, but we still remain, at heart, a person with low or high self-esteem. Just as people differ in their level of self-esteem, they can also differ in how changeable it is.
It is thought to be more changeable in people who are more sensitive to external events.
The psychologist Michael Kernis (cited in Larsen and Buss, 2008), for example, believes that more changeable self-esteem is found in people who are more sensitive to situations in which society will judge them in some way, who worry too much about the impression they have of themselves, who focus too much on social sources of evaluation and who react to such evaluation with anger.
Interestingly, changeable self-esteem has been shown to be one of the factors that contribute to depression: some researchers think that it arises as a result of sensitivity to situations that damage our self-image.
Are there gender differences in self-esteem?
The changes in self-esteem that occur over the course of life differ between men and women. In childhood, boys and girls have the same level of self-esteem, but during adolescence self-esteem grows stronger in males and weaker in females, so that by young adulthood there is already a large difference in the average level of self-esteem between women and men.
Of course, this trend is not the same for everyone: Buss and Larsen (2008) state that women with certain personality traits, such as a sense of humour and being communicative, are likely even to experience an increase in self-esteem over their lifetime, while those who are irritable and hostile are more likely to experience a drop in self-esteem.
In men, the personality traits linked to an increase in self-esteem are emotional reserve, being relaxed and their own subjective impression that they are physically attractive, while a drop in self-esteem can be seen in those who are prone to anxiety, stress and persistently dwelling on negative events.
One of the reasons why sociable and communicative women and relaxed, easy-going men experience an increase in self-esteem over time is that their self-concept matches cultural expectations, that is, the ideal of how a particular gender should behave: women are expected to be caring and warm, and men to be reserved and emotionally stable.
Tips for building and improving self-esteem
Make your self-concept more complex. Try to have as many interests as possible and to take part in as many different activities as you can. Remember that you are not only a student, a family member, a friend or an excellent athlete, but all of these at once.
Set realistic goals and expectations. Expectations that are too high will be hard to meet, and you will easily be disappointed if you fail, which will have a negative effect on your self-esteem
Let go of perfectionism. Nobody is perfect, and that includes you.
Instead of “I have to do this perfectly”, adopt the approach “I have to do this well enough”.
Do not compare yourself with others. You have different goals, interests, abilities and needs from other people. Think about what makes you personally happy and spend your time on that rather than trying to be like others.
If you must compare yourself with someone, compare yourself with an earlier version of yourself and admire the progress you have made in a particular area.
Put a stop to your inner “critic”. When you make a mistake or think you could have done something better, turn your attention instead to what you did well, and try to look objectively at the reasons for the mistake so that you can avoid it next time.
“Update” your self-image. Do not criticise yourself if you used to be better at something than you are now.
It is normal for people to change, and to become better at some things over time and worse at others because we no longer have the time to devote to them. Focus instead on your current strengths.
Offer help and support to the people around you. Ask your friends whether they need help with studying, see whether you can help your parents with household chores, and so on. If you make life better for others, you will see yourself as a better person and your self-esteem will grow.
For those who want to know more:
Berk, L. E. (2008). Psihologija cjeloživotnog obrazovanja. Jastrebarsko: Naklada Slap.
Larsen, R. J., Buss. D.
M. (2008). Psihologija ličnosti. Jastrebarsko: Naklada Slap.
Pervin, L. A., Cervone, D., John, O. P. (2008). Psihologija ličnosti: teorije i istraživanja. Zagreb: Školska knjiga.
Aronson, E., Wilson, T. D., Akert, R. M. (2005). Socijalna psihologija. Zagreb: Mate.