about 9 min read
Come on, admit it: you surely know that feeling of disappointment and anger when a fellow student gets a better mark than you in an exam, even though you are convinced you worked harder? You have probably also found yourself feeling unhappy because one of your friends has a richer social life than you, even though you consider yourself the more pleasant and fun person. If you think back to early childhood, you can find traces of dissatisfaction and resentment of other people’s happiness even then: how many times were you furious because your brothers and sisters got a toy you wanted so much?
Even if these feelings sometimes make you feel like a bad person, don’t worry, because we are all “green” with envy from time to time. In other words, envy is a universal feeling; no one is spared from it. Even so, it can and must be fought, and to resist it successfully we first need to understand it well.
Why do we envy others?
By its nature, envy is a malicious, powerful and all-consuming feeling that combines anger, sadness, rage and fear. It is an experience marked by hostility and aggression towards the person we envy, and it can leave us feeling constantly dissatisfied regardless of our actual achievements.
It arises because we are constantly comparing ourselves with other people, consciously or unconsciously, while misjudging our own strengths and weaknesses. If the outcome of these comparisons is negative for us, that is, if we judge that someone has more of certain qualities or achievements than we do, the ground is fertile for envy to grow.
It should be said, however, that the experience of envy is highly subjective: it is not another person’s achievements in themselves that cause envy, but our own sense of dissatisfaction and disappointment, because we assume that their success makes them happier than us.
According to the psychologist Abraham Tesser and his self-evaluation maintenance theory, one of the causes of envy is the feeling that our self-concept is threatened by another person’s behaviour.
More precisely, if we see that someone is better than us in some area despite our efforts, our self-esteem takes a heavy blow, and the unpleasant feeling of being worth less leads to a wish to destroy the other person’s achievement.
Tesser points out, however, that how much our self-esteem is threatened and how much envy we feel depend on two things: how close we are to the person and how important the area in which we are comparing ourselves is to our identity.
Although we often behave well towards people close to us, enjoying their successes and helping them through various difficulties, we are more likely to feel envious of their achievements than of something strangers have and we do not. The reason is that people tend to compare themselves with others who are similar to them in some way and who are close to them.
Secondly, not every success of the people close to us makes us envious, only achievements in areas we consider valuable. For example, if our friend is doing extremely well at university, we will probably envy them if we also want to be an excellent student. On the other hand, if the same person owns many material things that we do not care much about, that is, things that are not important to our sense of identity, we will not be particularly envious.
Are envy and jealousy the same thing?
Although the two words are sometimes used as synonyms, they describe different things.
Unlike jealousy, which usually arises in a relationship between three people and is the fear of losing something we already have because of another person (e.g. the fear that someone else will take our partner away), envy arises between two people and shows itself as the wish to be the one who takes something from someone else. For example, in the context of romantic relationships, we may envy someone for his or her partner and want that partner for ourselves.
Does envy affect our health?
Besides filling us with a sense of deep unhappiness and dissatisfaction, envy also harms our physical and mental health.
People who often envy others experience a great deal of stress and more often suffer from symptoms of depression, because they constantly compare themselves with others and focus on the ways in which others are better than them. In addition, they see doctors more often with complaints about poor health, and they are also more likely to have a heart attack or develop an illness with fatal consequences.
How does an envious person behave?
One of the most important signs of envy is malicious pleasure. This is so widespread among people that the Germans even have a word, schadenfreude, for taking pleasure in someone else’s misfortune.
Envious people can usually be recognised by the way they gloat when someone they envy has lost what they had, and you may hear them say things like “It’s their own fault”, “The higher they fly, the harder they fall” and so on. Taking pleasure in other people’s troubles is thought to be a feeling with which envious people feed their hatred and stir up even more aggression and hostility towards the target of their envy.
Besides malicious pleasure, envy can also be recognised in the lies and slander someone uses against their target.
This is a subtle strategy with which envious people try to destroy the success of the person they envy, and it shows in behaviour such as deliberately distorting the truth about the person we envy, belittling their worth, keeping quiet about their merits, etc. Such behaviour can actually be understood as a form of revenge that the envious person uses against their target, and this revenge is then rationalised by the “fact” that the person we envy is to blame for us not having something they have.
In other words, we think revenge is justified because we feel in some way attacked by the target of our envy.
Finally, envy can also be recognised in the insincere communication of people who envy us. For example, although someone says they are happy about our success, their verbal and non-verbal communication may not match, so their words may not be accompanied by a genuine smile.
Secondly, an envious person may be so affected by something we have achieved that they “accidentally” forget to congratulate us on our success, even though everyone else already has.
In what kinds of relationships does envy appear?
As already mentioned, envy appears above all in close relationships. For example, we are ready to enjoy our friends’ successes and feel proud of them as long as they achieve them in areas we do not consider important.
However, even when someone is our friend, we find it hard to bear that they are better than us at something: a study by Tesser and Smith (1980) showed that, after people fail at a task that matters to them, 75% of them are not willing to help their friends complete that task successfully.
Envy also appears in relationships between family members. It may arise if we feel our parents give more attention and love to our brothers and sisters than to us.
In addition, envy may be caused by the impression that our brothers and sisters are better than us in some important area, such as intelligence or popularity, and envy is more likely the closer we are to them in age. Because people care enormously about not being outdone in the things that matter to them, they often go so far as to choose different careers from their brothers and sisters so that they can stand out. However, envy can also arise between parents and children: one study showed that children had a more tense and colder relationship with their father when they worked in the same field (Tesser, 1980).
Little tricks for reducing envy
Instead of envying someone, try to learn something from them. If you see that someone is more successful than you at something, envy will certainly not help you catch up with them. Instead, ask that person to explain how they achieved their success so that you can achieve it too.
Change your perspective: focus on improving your performance in a particular area, not on the fact that you are worse than someone else.
Concentrating on your strengths and on the ways you can use them to succeed is a constructive strategy that can help you avoid feelings of inferiority and envy.
If you simply cannot improve your performance, think about whether that area really matters so much to you. For example, if someone is consistently better than you at a hobby despite your efforts, it is better to change your hobby than to struggle with feelings of envy.
Talk to someone about your feelings of envy. Talking will help keep your feelings of dissatisfaction from turning into bitterness and hostility towards the target of your envy.
The person you talk to may also help you see exactly why you feel envious and what you could do to change it.
Understand that someone else’s success is not automatically your failure. Whether someone succeeds or fails at something has no effect on us at all.
The reason is simple: our level of dissatisfaction will stay the same until we do something with our own life, regardless of what is happening in someone else’s.
Never engage in hostile behaviour towards the person you envy. You will only harm yourself: your self-esteem will suffer, your relationship with the person you envy will be ruined, and probably also your relationships with other people around you if they find out how you have behaved.
Stop thinking about other people’s lives and focus on your own. Instead of wasting all your energy following what is happening in other people’s lives, think about how you could improve your own.
What makes you happy and interests you, and what could you spend more time on? Are there activities you have never tried but could start? If you actively focus on building the best possible life for yourself, you will not only largely free yourself from envy, but you will also become a happier and more fulfilled person in general.
For those who want to know more:
Aronson, E., Wilson, T. D., Akert, R. M. (2005). Socijalna psihologija. Zagreb: Mate.
Čorić, Š. Š. (2008). Žuta neman zavist. Ili kako uspješnije izjedati sebe i druge. Zagreb: Glas Koncila.
Tesser, A. (1980). Self-esteem maintenance in family dynamics.
Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 39, 77-91.